Chat
6.1K views · 1 week ago
TJump made the case live on Atlas: "Can morality be objective without God? All theistic arguments/evidence indicate naturalism more than theism." Archduke Pierogi the Certified, Dame Cheddar the Deeply Unserious, Chef Waffle the Great and Daniel Collins took the stage to challenge it. The replay runs 1 hour 21 minutes, with the full transcript. Tagged #atheism and #morality.
Log in to join the conversation.
SES1 · 1 week ago
TJump: "morality as a law of physics" - Calling morality a 'law of physics' is a basic category error. Laws of physics describe what matter invariably does; moral laws prescribe what agents ought to do. If morality were a law of physics, committing an evil act would be as physically impossible as traveling faster than the speed of light. When asked what evidence would change his mind about God, TJump mentioned scientific evidence. But 1) science only explores the physical world. 2) Science only accepts naturalistic conclusions. So that's a problem to say you want empirical natural evidence for God. He is just filtering everything through his ungrounded naturalistic presumptions. He says he wants to be logical. Then logically defend naturalism! Asking "Who caused God?" is a category error. The classical philosophical conception of God is an uncaused, self-existent, necessary being. If there is not an uncaused 1st cause, then you have the Infinite Regress Problem. If person A needs $20 and borrows from person B, who must borrow from C into infinity, the money never actually arrives unless someone at the end of the line loans it 1st. A non-physical intelligent metaphysically necessary designer solves the infinite regress problem, the origin of DNA, morality, the naturalistic brain problem, etc. The "God hypothesis" is the single best explanation for a myriad of issues. The only objection is it's not natural/physical. Science routinely accepts, uses, and builds models around entities that have never been directly observed or physically detected - dark matter, dark energy, the multiverse; these are not just dismissed out of hand like the God - hypothesis. It's just a naturalistic presumption and bias.
SES1 · 1 week ago
TJump never presents an actual argument. He just bats away with his naturalistic presumptions and the error of "consensus" - consensus is not data nor an argument. He mentions DNA then says it's a "confirmed natural process". But how is a blind, goalless, purposeless, unguided, unintelligent process a BETTER explanation than a designer? And yes, science appeals to a designer ALL THE TIME, even in biology. Just not in this case. Why? It seems a designer is just eliminated a priori - to protect naturalism. To say natural selection helped form DNA in the first is unscientific - The very first strand of functional DNA (or RNA) had no ancestors that reproduced, and it produced no offspring until an entire supporting apparatus was already operational. DNA is not merely a complex chemical; it is an informational code that depends on a closed, interdependent loop: DNA cannot replicate, transcribe, or repair itself without specialized protein enzymes. Those specific protein enzymes cannot be constructed without the sequence-specific coding instructions stored in DNA. Neither can produce "offspring" without the other already present. Appealing to natural selection to build either side of the loop fails because selection only starts AFTER the entire machine is already running. No, science does not know how the first DNA originated. abiogenesis is one of the most stubborn unsolved problems. Outside of pre-existing living cells, self-replicating molecules are not spontaneously created in nature today, and science has never observed them forming "in the wild.". No, we do not have infinite time for chance to work. We know the amount of time since the Big Bang and how many particles there are in the known universe. Thus, there is a limited number of chances - 2.33 x10^152 or so. The combinatorial space for even a average-sized protein of 150 amino acids requires roughly 7.2x10^195 possible sequence configurations to locate a functional fold via natural process.
SES1 · 1 week ago
"The consensus of scholars says that the resurrection didn't happen" - 1) consensus is not an argument. 2) Are the scholars who reject do so on the data or their naturalistic bias? Fine tuning via chance or necessity: Appeals to "consensus" and design isn't even an option! Why? Intelligent beings routinely fine-tune things every day.... Stenger largely glossed over the most severe fine-tuning problems, particularly the cosmological constant. Altering these does not result in "compensating" physics; it results in a universe that re-collapses into a black hole. The physical brain problem: Critical thinking requires that our beliefs are formed because of logical grounds - evaluating premises, detecting fallacies, and following the normative rules of validity. A neuron fires physical force, now because of the law of non-contradiction, modus ponens, or propositional truth. Under naturalism, every thought, belief, and deduction is 100% determined by prior physical causes (brain chemistry, genetics, external stimuli). If thought is completely determined by physical mechanics, rational evaluation is an illusion. Yet here we are trying to think critically. That's why naturalism is a logical contradiction. Jump mentions religions as the result of chemical reactions in the brain. However, this naturalistic/evolutionary brain 95% of the people who ever lived a FALSE belief. That's why you cannot trust the naturalistic/evolutionary brain; it's not a truth seeker - it seeks survival. Thus rationality can't be accounted for under naturalism. "God is immoral because He drowned babies". How did the Creator and sustainer of life cheat them out of life? Under what obligation is God under to give anyone X amount of time on earth? I never heard a critic give a cogent answer to this. Also, God didn't end their existence; He just ended their existence on earth and transferred it to another plane of existence. TJump touches on this when he mentions "teleporting them"!
SES1 · 1 week ago
When TJump says there is no evidence for God, that is a claim. How does he support that? And there is evidence against God, especially Christianity. Another claim, with no support. To say that matter and energy are eternal is not supported by any evidence. It's a faith statement. The best evidence we have is that Matter and energy have a finite past. The first law of thermodynamics does NOT mean matter and energy are eternal. The 1st Law describes how energy behaves across time given the prior existence of spacetime and matter/energy. Saying "matter/energy cannot be created" within the rules of the existing cosmos does not logically entail "matter/energy has existed for an infinite series of past moments. If a "first cause" is purely physical (matter, fields, or quantum energy), it operates via mechanistic causation, an effect follows necessarily whenever the sufficient physical conditions are present. Thus our universe should be came into being infinitely long ago. There is no physical mechanism by which a blind, timeless physical state can sit quietly from eternity and then suddenly decide to undergo a state change at a finite point in the past. A personal agent with free will breaks this deadlock. An agent can exist changelessly and timelessly (or in an undifferentiated state) and freely initiate a new causal chain without being mechanically determined by prior conditions. Thus, an intelligent agent is a better explanation than purposeless, goalless, unintelligent, blind matter/energy. To say "pineapples are an emergent thing" sounds great until you realize that pineapples have DNA. And DNA is a complex code. The ATP synthase is a DNA-based micromachine that is made of several parts; each part has several proteins, and each protein is made of a chain of amino acids in a specific order. There is not enough time in the universe for a single protein to have formed by a purposeless, goalless, unintelligent, blind process. A rational intelligence could have.